METHUSELAH ARCHIVE CLAIMS
Claim · 1951 · Krebiozen Cancer Treatment

Krebiozen produces objective antitumor responses in cancer patients, including measurable tumor reduction and extended survival, as shown by enzyme-analysis data from clinical observations.

surrogaterefuted intervention Krebiozen Cancer Treatment

Andrew C. Ivy announced this claim at a press conference in Chicago in 1951, presenting 22 case observations in which he reported that a majority of patients showed favorable objective responses (Ivy, Science 1951, PMID 14866224). He supported the claim using what he called “enzyme analysis,” a non-standard methodology that was not independently reproducible. The American Medical Association’s status report six months later (JAMA 1951, PMID 14873580) reviewed the same 22 cases and found the data too incomplete and uncontrolled to support the claim, noting that several patients Ivy had counted as improved had died of cancer. The National Cancer Institute later reviewed 504 cases submitted by the Durovic brothers and also concluded that Krebiozen did not demonstrate antitumor activity. No independently controlled trial ever confirmed efficacy.

Sources

  1. Krebiozen — Ivy AC. "Krebiozen." Science. 1951 Sep 14;114(2959):285–286. PMID 14866224.
  2. STATUS report on "krebiozen" — [No authors listed]. "STATUS report on 'krebiozen'." Journal of the American Medical Association. 1951 Oct 27;147(9):864–873. PMID 14873580.
  3. Unproven methods of cancer management. Krebiozen and carcalon — [No authors listed]. "Unproven methods of cancer management. Krebiozen and carcalon." CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians. 1973 Mar-Apr;23(2):111–115. PMID 4196527.
  4. The krebiozen story. Is cancer quackery dead? — Holland JF. "The krebiozen story. Is cancer quackery dead?" JAMA. 1967 Apr 17;200(3):213–218. PMID 6071435.