METHUSELAH ARCHIVE SOURCES / BOMBAY-HC-ELECTROPATHY-MEDICOS-2001

Electropathy Medicos Of India (Central Board) v. The State Of Maharashtra & Ors.

primary document · 2001
type:primary document
year:2001
citation:High Court of Judicature at Bombay (A. P. Shah and S. A. Bobde, JJ.). Electropathy Medicos Of India (Central Board) v. The State Of Maharashtra & Ors., Writ Petition No. 863 of 1988, decided 13 August 2001; reported at 2002(1) ALL MR 105.
LINK
https://nearlaw.com/PDF/MumbaiHC/2002/2002(1)-ALL-MR-105.html
SUMMARY
Full judgment text directly fetched via curl (HTTP 200; this project's automated verify-quotes fetcher false-positives on this page because it loads an unrelated cdnjs.cloudflare.com script tag, so this record's content is paraphrased in the published bundle rather than placed in a verify-quotes block). The petitioner society, running a diploma-granting institution teaching 'electropathy'/'electrohomeopathy' (Bachelor of Electropathy, Medicine and Surgery), challenged a 1987 government order closing its courses. The Bombay High Court held the practice unrecognized as a system of medicine in India or anywhere else, including Italy, where it is alleged to have been discovered in 1865 (matching Mattei's own claimed date of discovery), and dismissed the petition, ordering closure of the courses, a ban on the society granting further affiliations, a fee refund with 18% interest to enrolled students, and directing the State Government to close affiliated institutions and pursue practitioners under the Maharashtra Medical Practitioners Act, 1961.
NOTES

Primary judicial source establishing that Indian courts have directly and specifically rejected the modern namesake practice’s claim to be a recognized system of medicine, tying the practice explicitly to Mattei’s 1865 discovery date. Paraphrased in the published bundle rather than quoted verbatim (see summary for why).