Wilhelm Reich
"Scientific matters can only be clarified by prolonged, faithful bona fide observations in friendly exchange of opinion, never by litigation."
Wilhelm Reich (1897-1957) trained as a physician in Vienna and became a prominent member of Sigmund Freud’s psychoanalytic circle before breaking with Freud over his own theory that neurosis was rooted in blocked “orgastic” sexual energy. Following that break and years of political and professional conflict in Europe, Reich coined the term “orgone energy” while living in Oslo, Norway in the mid-to-late 1930s, then emigrated to the United States in September 1939. In 1941 he purchased land at Rangeley, Maine and built Orgonon, the home, laboratory, and research institute from which he directed the Wilhelm Reich Foundation and the Orgone Institute Press. Reich personally combined the roles the FDA’s 1954 complaint targeted: sole author of the orgone-energy doctrine, designer of the accumulator, and head of the organization that sold and rented the device and its literature. His February 1954 letter to the trial judge, quoted above, framed the case as an assault on scientific freedom rather than a question the court had authority to test; he never answered the complaint on the merits. His eventual status is publicly disconfirmed: a federal court found the claims baseless in 1954, a jury convicted him of criminal contempt in 1956 for continuing to ship and rent the devices, and he died in the custody of the Lewisburg, Pennsylvania federal penitentiary in 1957.